I agree with most of what you’re saying, but I think size matters here. America and Europe are vastly different in scale, and you can still find strong communities and a collective mindset in rural parts of the U.S. I’d argue the Cajuns of the bayou, whose way of life depends heavily on one another, embody many of the same values people often associate with Europe’s close-knit communities.
Great article; it offers a real wake-up call regarding both sides of the Atlantic.
In Europe, and especially in Southern Europe (France, Italy, Spain), we place a high value on quality of life: basking in the sun, sharing a meal with family, or grabbing a coffee with friends. We are also very mindful of food quality. Often, the saying goes that here we work to live, whereas in the U.S., people live to work.
The core of your piece reminded me of my first essay, which you can read at this link: The Tasting Menu of Freedom, Fast. I think you’ll enjoy it.
Faced with these two models, we often ask ourselves the same question: Why would you want so much money if you can’t enjoy it? Which option is better? That is a question everyone must answer for themselves based on their own priorities.
People don’t get that European aesthetic, ease, whatever you want to call it, IS wealth. A wealth Europe has been building for millennia and America for 2.5 centuries. But America is catching up. Fast. Ten years ago I’d have agreed that wealthy neighborhoods are the ones that get European charm. But it’s spilling out into small town America with unmistakably American charm. This weekend my fiancée and I ran in a 5k around a charming brick-built post industrial town and stepped into our town cafe for a nice cold foam before hand. After we bought shawarma and grape leaves from a middle eastern food truck and I checked out the vintage motorcycle shop while they were making it. Then we went to her nephew’s baseball games, which now all feature walk-on music for the 12 year old kids league and are live streamed. Then we met up with friends for the afternoon at a brewery with sweeping views of our little New England valley, ate hot honey pepperoni pizza and took in life while a solid 50 kids of the adults in attendance got to run around to their hearts content in the massive brewery grounds. It didn’t feel very soulless and we do it pulling 200k a year as a household with ~2k a month in costs. You’re basically aristocracy if you’re doing that in Europe.
Yeah, interstate driving sucks. Will it when American markets push self driving cars over the line?
“Rather than claiming Europe is clearly better than the US, I’m saying it is simply different, and the vast majority of people born and raised in Europe will prefer it there, and the same is true with the US, because that is what it means to come from a culture”.
Having lived in several countries I think this pretty well sums up the article. I despair the American food culture with so much corn syrup and seed oil over processed glop sold as “food”.
Walking through an Italian grocery store you find a huge aisle of predominantly Italian wine, an aisle each of dry and fresh pasta, 10 meters of olive oils and a baked goods section any home baker would be proud of. The same experience in an American store gets you a full aisle of soda, another of processed junk food and yet another of breakfast cereal.
The sandwich I bought at the Venice airport was better than most of those put out by the chain deli’s in the USA… so sad.
The cosmopolitan elite have a great deal of shared culture, so their spaces can all be converted into whatever they want it to be. The more provincial population is going to be much more unique to the area. In the US that manifests in a rural population that uses Walmart to have the most stuff they can get, and a poor urban population that is just trying to survive the jungle of urban decay. Trying to bring the sort of cosmopolitan aesthetics you wax about in this article will fail because the population never developed any interest in it like those living amongst the marble of antiquity. If you don't like "Live Laugh Love" signs or graffiti then you aren't a good fit for the aesthetics of the lower half of America.
It’s an interesting argument but I think the unacknowledged point is the disparity in geography between the two continents.
America has an abundance of space that both makes individualism economically viable while making certain shared infrastructure and civil projects unviable. Part of Europe’s common wealth is simply a function of higher density, and spending time in higher density areas of the US can make it feel more European.
Meanwhile, Europe evolved over a period of time when the horse was the fastest mode of land travel for most people, directly shaping how cities developed, while America developed in tandem with railroads and automobiles.
The last thing worth noting is that Europe has a more distinct social ranking by profession as compared to income level. What I mean by that is a trades person in America has much better prospects if they’re motivated to work hard, but would have a low social standing and prospective income in Europe. While in Europe, a mediocre university graduate would have higher social standing and prospective income than a trades person. Europe may appear more egalitarian in some regards but is more rigid and class based than America is.
You can find a cute cafe with fresh baked goods in any small town in America, by the way, and I promise you cheap hotels in Europe have plenty of terrible food.
Which isn't to say there's not real differences here, but I think the article would be more interesting if you connected this with the actual history of American urban architecture because it's a lot more complex and challenging than "individualism and money lol"
"with the US undeniably wealthier in easily quantified material terms"
But: for whom?
I've lived very happily, in Berlin, for 36 years, now. Have lived very happily, here, with my Lovely (classical musician) Wife (we have a genius Daughter) for 22 years. Old friends visit from the US, occasionally: they all tend to have big houses (we have a nice flat with a big garden, a rarity for Central Berlin), 2.5 cars (we don't need a car) and hundreds of thousands in debt added to stress-filled years. We have, literally, zero debt (only resorting to a credit card when forced to). We do whatever we feel like doing most days of the week; we do a Greek island four times a year. My Old Friends are walking marquees of Negative-Dollar-Value-Wealth, and incipient life-threatening health issues, but what can I do for them? They didn't listen to me 36 years ago. They all warned me I was "crazy".
Is this a European thing, or a North American thing (because frankly, outside of Quebec, Canadian life is almost indistinguishable from American)?
In that, if you replace cathedrals with temples, do you not see the same public life underpinnings across Asia and Latin America? Is there a real difference between the public squares of Italy and Korea/China/Mexico?
To understand how the US got to be how it is (and why Europe is different) read “The Geography of Nowhere: The Rise and Decline of America's Man-Made Landscape” by James Howard Kunstler
Unlike you, I'm kinda one-sided on this. Even the worst "European" country I have spent time in (UK by the way), seems a bit more pleasant in every way that matters to me. Were it not for family ties and the complicated and dicey prospect of gaining citizenship, I would be Irish or Danish or Swedish ASAP. Ironically my father could have gained Irish citizenship and my mother could have gained Swedish citizenship (she is still alive but the process would be daunting for her) had they ever had the inclination. Alas I am too far removed by one gen.
Travel is a Fool's Paradise.
I agree with most of what you’re saying, but I think size matters here. America and Europe are vastly different in scale, and you can still find strong communities and a collective mindset in rural parts of the U.S. I’d argue the Cajuns of the bayou, whose way of life depends heavily on one another, embody many of the same values people often associate with Europe’s close-knit communities.
Great article; it offers a real wake-up call regarding both sides of the Atlantic.
In Europe, and especially in Southern Europe (France, Italy, Spain), we place a high value on quality of life: basking in the sun, sharing a meal with family, or grabbing a coffee with friends. We are also very mindful of food quality. Often, the saying goes that here we work to live, whereas in the U.S., people live to work.
The core of your piece reminded me of my first essay, which you can read at this link: The Tasting Menu of Freedom, Fast. I think you’ll enjoy it.
Faced with these two models, we often ask ourselves the same question: Why would you want so much money if you can’t enjoy it? Which option is better? That is a question everyone must answer for themselves based on their own priorities.
People don’t get that European aesthetic, ease, whatever you want to call it, IS wealth. A wealth Europe has been building for millennia and America for 2.5 centuries. But America is catching up. Fast. Ten years ago I’d have agreed that wealthy neighborhoods are the ones that get European charm. But it’s spilling out into small town America with unmistakably American charm. This weekend my fiancée and I ran in a 5k around a charming brick-built post industrial town and stepped into our town cafe for a nice cold foam before hand. After we bought shawarma and grape leaves from a middle eastern food truck and I checked out the vintage motorcycle shop while they were making it. Then we went to her nephew’s baseball games, which now all feature walk-on music for the 12 year old kids league and are live streamed. Then we met up with friends for the afternoon at a brewery with sweeping views of our little New England valley, ate hot honey pepperoni pizza and took in life while a solid 50 kids of the adults in attendance got to run around to their hearts content in the massive brewery grounds. It didn’t feel very soulless and we do it pulling 200k a year as a household with ~2k a month in costs. You’re basically aristocracy if you’re doing that in Europe.
Yeah, interstate driving sucks. Will it when American markets push self driving cars over the line?
“Rather than claiming Europe is clearly better than the US, I’m saying it is simply different, and the vast majority of people born and raised in Europe will prefer it there, and the same is true with the US, because that is what it means to come from a culture”.
Having lived in several countries I think this pretty well sums up the article. I despair the American food culture with so much corn syrup and seed oil over processed glop sold as “food”.
Walking through an Italian grocery store you find a huge aisle of predominantly Italian wine, an aisle each of dry and fresh pasta, 10 meters of olive oils and a baked goods section any home baker would be proud of. The same experience in an American store gets you a full aisle of soda, another of processed junk food and yet another of breakfast cereal.
The sandwich I bought at the Venice airport was better than most of those put out by the chain deli’s in the USA… so sad.
The cosmopolitan elite have a great deal of shared culture, so their spaces can all be converted into whatever they want it to be. The more provincial population is going to be much more unique to the area. In the US that manifests in a rural population that uses Walmart to have the most stuff they can get, and a poor urban population that is just trying to survive the jungle of urban decay. Trying to bring the sort of cosmopolitan aesthetics you wax about in this article will fail because the population never developed any interest in it like those living amongst the marble of antiquity. If you don't like "Live Laugh Love" signs or graffiti then you aren't a good fit for the aesthetics of the lower half of America.
I prefer life in Italy for all the reasons you mentioned
It’s an interesting argument but I think the unacknowledged point is the disparity in geography between the two continents.
America has an abundance of space that both makes individualism economically viable while making certain shared infrastructure and civil projects unviable. Part of Europe’s common wealth is simply a function of higher density, and spending time in higher density areas of the US can make it feel more European.
Meanwhile, Europe evolved over a period of time when the horse was the fastest mode of land travel for most people, directly shaping how cities developed, while America developed in tandem with railroads and automobiles.
The last thing worth noting is that Europe has a more distinct social ranking by profession as compared to income level. What I mean by that is a trades person in America has much better prospects if they’re motivated to work hard, but would have a low social standing and prospective income in Europe. While in Europe, a mediocre university graduate would have higher social standing and prospective income than a trades person. Europe may appear more egalitarian in some regards but is more rigid and class based than America is.
You can find a cute cafe with fresh baked goods in any small town in America, by the way, and I promise you cheap hotels in Europe have plenty of terrible food.
Which isn't to say there's not real differences here, but I think the article would be more interesting if you connected this with the actual history of American urban architecture because it's a lot more complex and challenging than "individualism and money lol"
"with the US undeniably wealthier in easily quantified material terms"
But: for whom?
I've lived very happily, in Berlin, for 36 years, now. Have lived very happily, here, with my Lovely (classical musician) Wife (we have a genius Daughter) for 22 years. Old friends visit from the US, occasionally: they all tend to have big houses (we have a nice flat with a big garden, a rarity for Central Berlin), 2.5 cars (we don't need a car) and hundreds of thousands in debt added to stress-filled years. We have, literally, zero debt (only resorting to a credit card when forced to). We do whatever we feel like doing most days of the week; we do a Greek island four times a year. My Old Friends are walking marquees of Negative-Dollar-Value-Wealth, and incipient life-threatening health issues, but what can I do for them? They didn't listen to me 36 years ago. They all warned me I was "crazy".
American brainwashing is second to none.
Is this a European thing, or a North American thing (because frankly, outside of Quebec, Canadian life is almost indistinguishable from American)?
In that, if you replace cathedrals with temples, do you not see the same public life underpinnings across Asia and Latin America? Is there a real difference between the public squares of Italy and Korea/China/Mexico?
Curiousitywise, where would you put Australia in that comparison?
down under
better than upside down....
It's not really clear that the American side is winning, given the US's failure in things such as universal healthcare and crime rates.
Crimes rates, which I'm sure you're concerned about, are down across the board in American cities
And yet they're still high by European standards.
To understand how the US got to be how it is (and why Europe is different) read “The Geography of Nowhere: The Rise and Decline of America's Man-Made Landscape” by James Howard Kunstler
https://a.co/d/09HcMba7
Unlike you, I'm kinda one-sided on this. Even the worst "European" country I have spent time in (UK by the way), seems a bit more pleasant in every way that matters to me. Were it not for family ties and the complicated and dicey prospect of gaining citizenship, I would be Irish or Danish or Swedish ASAP. Ironically my father could have gained Irish citizenship and my mother could have gained Swedish citizenship (she is still alive but the process would be daunting for her) had they ever had the inclination. Alas I am too far removed by one gen.
The true core reason that explains this difference is that Europeans are deeply influenced by aristocratic values, while Americans are not.
See my blog for a deeper dive: https://bellieve.substack.com/p/on-european-vs-american-work-ethics.